Question 1

What happens to SAP custom code after ECC end of maintenance?

Accepted Answer

After SAP ends mainstream support for ECC (currently scheduled for 2027), customers face tremendous pressure to migrate to SAP's latest ERP platform, S/4HANA. When making this transition, legacy custom code cannot simply be moved over as-is. S/4HANA is not merely an evolution of ECC; it is a complete rewrite designed specifically to take advantage of SAP's HANA in-memory database. Because of these foundational changes to the software, database technology, table structures, and ABAP language syntax, the move introduces hundreds of thousands of incompatibilities in legacy custom code. Consequently, any custom code written for ECC requires extensive changes to continue operating smoothly on S/4HANA. Organizations must analyze their existing codebase, safely decommission code that is no longer used, and comprehensively remediate and optimize the remaining custom code to ensure full compatibility with the new S/4HANA architecture.

Question 2

What is the SAP ECC end-of-maintenance deadline?

Accepted Answer

SAP has set the deadline for the end of mainstream support for SAP ECC in 2027. After this 2027 deadline, customers will have the option to purchase extended support at a premium until 2030, but this will only be available on a case-by-case basis. Although SAP has extended the ECC end-of-support date in the past, the company has explicitly stated that it will not extend it again.

Question 3

Do we need to transform custom code before moving to S/4HANA?

Accepted Answer

Yes, transforming custom code is a necessary step before or during a move to SAP S/4HANA. S/4HANA is not merely an evolution of SAP ECC; it is a complete rewrite designed specifically to take advantage of SAP's HANA in-memory database. Because of these foundational changes to the software, underlying database technology, table structures, and ABAP language syntax, the migration introduces hundreds of thousands of incompatibilities within legacy custom code. Consequently, any custom code written for ECC that you plan to retain requires extensive changes to continue operating smoothly. Organizations must remediate and optimize this code to ensure mandatory S/4HANA compatibility, maintain system stability, and avoid costly production outages.

Question 4

How does ECC end-of-support impact custom enhancements and modifications?

Accepted Answer

The end of mainstream support for SAP ECC in 2027 forces organizations to migrate to S/4HANA, which significantly impacts legacy custom enhancements and modifications. Because S/4HANA is a complete rewrite designed specifically for the HANA in-memory database, legacy code and modifications cannot simply be moved over to the new environment as-is. Specifically, the transition impacts custom enhancements and modifications in the following ways: Widespread Incompatibilities: Foundational changes to the software, underlying database technology, table structures, and ABAP language syntax introduce hundreds of thousands of custom code incompatibilities that must be remediated for the code to continue functioning. Reconciling Modifications: Any modifications previously made to standard SAP objects must be carefully evaluated and reconciled during the system upgrade using SAP transactions like SPDD (for data dictionary objects) and SPAU (for standard code objects). This process is crucial for determining which custom changes should be retained in the new S/4HANA environment and which objects can be reverted to the SAP standard. Modernizing Custom Fields: Legacy enhancements like "Classical Custom Fields" (e.g., legacy table appends) are incompatible with modern SAP Clean Core principles. These must be transformed and migrated to new Key User custom field extensions so they can function properly with modern S/4HANA innovations, including native SAP Fiori apps, standard CDS views, and APIs. Ultimately, the ECC end-of-support requires organizations to comprehensively analyze, remediate, and optimize their custom ABAP codebase to guarantee S/4HANA compatibility, avoid system instability, and align with future-ready Clean Core architecture.

Question 5

What is SAP custom code transformation in an SAP S/4HANA migration?

Accepted Answer

SAP custom code transformation during an S/4HANA migration is the process of adapting, remediating, and optimizing a company's legacy ABAP code to ensure it functions correctly, securely, and efficiently in the new SAP S/4HANA environment. Because S/4HANA is a complete rewrite designed specifically for the HANA in-memory database, migrating from legacy SAP ECC introduces widespread incompatibilities related to data models, underlying database technology, and ABAP language syntax. If these incompatibilities are not addressed, the legacy custom code can cause severe functional errors, system instability, and production outages. A comprehensive custom code transformation process goes beyond simple "find and replace" syntax fixes and encompasses several critical steps: Compatibility Remediation: Resolving mandatory syntax errors and adapting legacy data structures to ensure the code interacts properly with the S/4HANA architecture and the HANA database. Performance Optimization: Applying SAP's "Golden Rules" for SQL and tuning the code to fully leverage the speed of the HANA in-memory database. Security and Stability: Hardening the code by detecting and correcting vulnerabilities (such as missing authorization checks or code injection risks) and removing potential runtime errors. Code Decommissioning: Identifying and safely deactivating obsolete or completely unused custom code, which drastically reduces the organization's technical debt and shrinks the scope of future maintenance. Clean Core Modernization: Refactoring code to implement current SAP ABAP guidelines and best practices, preparing the system for cloud-compliance (ABAP Cloud) and modern extensibility models. Traditionally, organizations relied on a massive deployment of developers to spend months or years manually identifying and rewriting these code issues. However, the modern standard is to use Intelligent Automation for the transformation. In an automated approach, tools like smartShift extract the custom codebase, parse it into a language-independent meta-model, and automatically apply thousands of AI-driven rules to rewrite the logic. The modernized, S/4HANA-compliant code is then automatically uploaded back into the target system—allowing millions of lines of code to be transformed in weeks with a 99.99% accuracy rate.

Question 6

How do you identify which custom code needs remediation before migration?

Accepted Answer

Identifying which custom code requires remediation before migration is accomplished through a comprehensive, automated evaluation of the entire SAP custom code repository using the smartShift Code Analysis solution and the Intelligent Automation Platform. This process goes beyond basic scanning by combining multiple analytical methods to precisely define the scope of transformation: Data Extraction and Usage Analysis: The process begins by extracting custom developments, object metadata, and historical production usage data utilizing sources like ST03N, UPL, SCMON, or SUSG. By evaluating this statistical data—ideally covering 13 months to capture year-end activities—the analysis separates actively used objects from unused ones. This crucial step allows organizations to safely decommission obsolete code, thereby drastically reducing technical debt and the overall scope of code that actually needs remediation. Deep Code Parsing and Meta-Modeling: The platform's Analysis Engine parses all custom code and re-engineers it into a language-independent meta-model. This allows the platform to comprehensively evaluate the logical constructs, data declarations, data flows, and complex inter-object dependencies across the entire system, rather than relying on simple pattern matching. Rule-Based Technical Evaluation: The platform evaluates every object in the meta-model against a library of over 240 AI-driven rulesets. This identifies mandatory changes for S/4HANA, HANA database, and Unicode compatibility, while also flagging code for performance optimization, security vulnerabilities, and ABAP modernization. Integration with SAP Standard Tools: The automated analysis integrates results from SAP's own tools, specifically the ABAP Test Cockpit (ATC) S/4HANA Readiness variant report and the Simplification List. The Analysis Engine combines these ATC results with its own deep-dive analysis to evaluate specific functional impacts, data model changes, and obsolete SAP components that require customer attention. Landscape Comparison and Reconciliation: To ensure the correct code is transformed, the analysis compares custom code across different system environments, such as Development, QA, and Production. This identifies version inconsistencies and source code conflicts, ensuring that obsolete objects in the production environment do not overwrite active development. Interface and Dependency Mapping: The analysis maps out all system interfaces, file access points, and external database calls, uncovering latent dependencies within the custom code that might break or require architectural realignment during the transition. By synthesizing these insights, the analysis generates actionable reports, risk scoring, and a precise, fixed-bid project plan that eliminates the guesswork from determining the remediation scope.

Question 7

Does all custom code need to be rewritten during SAP code transformation?

Accepted Answer

No, not all custom code needs to be manually rewritten or re-architected from scratch during an SAP code transformation. Instead of starting over, the transformation process focuses on efficiently adapting your existing codebase for the new environment. Here is how the process handles your custom code: Code Conversion vs. Replacement: Code transformation adapts and converts your existing code to be compatible with S/4HANA and the HANA database. This is a much more efficient approach than manually backwards-engineering code or developing new objects from scratch, which would require writing new requirements, documenting specifications, and composing pseudo-code. Decommissioning Unused Code: A significant portion of a typical SAP customer's legacy codebase is actually obsolete or no longer used. By evaluating historical SAP usage data, smartShift identifies this inactive code and safely deactivates or removes it. For example, customers often find that 30% to 50% of their custom code can simply be decommissioned rather than transformed. Automated Refactoring: For the active code that must be retained, smartShift uses its Intelligent Automation Platform to automatically refactor and rewrite the necessary syntax. This means your existing code is automatically modernized, secured, and optimized for performance by algorithms, entirely eliminating the need for developers to manually rewrite it.

Question 8

Can unused custom code be removed during transformation?

Accepted Answer

Yes, unused custom code can—and should—be removed during the transformation process. This practice is known as code decommissioning, which is the automated process of safely deactivating, removing, and archiving obsolete or unused custom code. Here is how the removal of unused code is handled during transformation: Data-Driven Usage Analysis: smartShift evaluates historical SAP statistical usage data (using sources like ST03N, UPL, SCMON, or SUSG) to accurately identify which custom objects are actively used and which have fallen into disuse. Dependency Mapping: Before any code is removed, smartShift performs a deep dependency analysis. This ensures that seemingly unused objects are not deactivated if they are still syntactically linked to active, necessary code. Flexible Removal Options: Decommissioning is tailored to an organization's risk tolerance. The code can either undergo "virtual deletion" (where the code is automatically commented out but left in place) or full physical deletion and removal. In all cases, a transport-based backup is created so the code can be easily recovered if it is ever needed in the future. The Benefits of Removing Unused Code: Retiring obsolete code drastically reduces your system's technical debt. Because unmaintained code often contains security vulnerabilities, removing it directly improves your overall SAP security posture. Furthermore, it yields significant cost savings by eliminating the future effort required to maintain, upgrade, and test code that your business no longer relies on. In practice, organizations typically find that a massive portion of their legacy code is obsolete. For example, during their respective SAP transformations, John Deere safely decommissioned 35% of their custom objects, and Jabil decommissioned 40% of their custom code, amounting to over 5,300 unused objects.

Question 9

How do you make custom code upgrade-safe after transformation?

Accepted Answer

To make custom code upgrade-safe after transformation, organizations must align their SAP environment with Clean Core principles. This involves shifting away from classical, monolithic, tightly coupled ABAP development toward modern, loosely coupled extensions. Key steps to achieve this include: Adopting ABAP Cloud Standards: Transforming the legacy codebase to comply with SAP's latest ABAP Cloud development syntax. This ensures compatibility with the SAP Business Technology Platform (BTP), eliminates outdated logic that threatens future upgrades, and makes the code cloud-ready. Migrating to Key User Custom Fields: Legacy "Classical Custom Fields" (such as legacy table appends) must be transformed into modern "Key User Custom Fields". This enables the custom fields to be natively used in SAP standard Fiori UIs, CDS views, and standard APIs without additional developer work, keeping the data model agile and upgrade-safe. Utilizing Released Objects and Public APIs: Redesigning extensions to rely fully on released SAP objects and whitelisted, public APIs rather than direct legacy table access or classic APIs. By utilizing automated solutions like smartShift's Clean Core Realization, legacy code and custom fields are automatically refactored to align with these standards. This ensures that the custom extensions are stable and can seamlessly consume future SAP innovations and version upgrades without friction.

Code Carve-out for SAP

Carve out all of the customization with no risk and no guesswork.

Accelerate divestitures and reorganizations by automatically extracting everything that needs to work, including all hidden dependencies.

Separate What Matters. Protect What Remains.

Precision Code Separation.

Clean Separation Without Disruption

Accelerated Divestiture Timelines

Transparent, Controlled Results

No Impact to Business Continuity

You'll meet tight deadlines with minimal business impact, and create a modern SAP landscape ready for what’s next.

SAP Carve-Outs Are Complex

Deep interdependencies between modules, exits, enhancements, data objects.

Limited visibility into what code is truly required for the new entity.

High risk of destabilizing both environments during separation.

Trial-and-error discovery and validation cycles that delay timelines.

Strict timelines dictated by legal agreements.

smartShift's automation-driven approach delivers clean, traceable carve-outs that cut time and risk from critical business transitions.

Precision Code Separation.

Precise Object Identification

Deep Dependency Mapping

Automated Repackaging

Guaranteed Reliability

The smartShift Advantage

Enterprise-Grade Accuracy and Speed

Predictable, Risk-Free Delivery

Trusted by Global SAP Leaders

Fast, Reliable Outcomes

Fixed price, fixed timeline, guaranteed delivery.

The Proven Leader in SAP Custom Code Modernization

Transformation Projects Completed

Lines of Code Transformed

Manual Labor Hours Eliminated

Fortune 500 Companies Choose smartShift

What our customers are saying

"You hear about S/4HANA upgrades going south. That did not happen to us. The number of defects we had after go-live was so tiny it was just incredible."

Talk to an SAP Custom Code Transformation Expert

Separate with Speed. Keep Systems Stable.

Learn More About Custom Code Transformation

Stop letting legacy code manage you.

The Custom Code Roadblock?

Near Zero Downtime beim S/4HANA-Umstieg – so gelingt End-to-End-Automatisierung im Retail